18
Our whole book club almost fell apart over a single chapter last month
We were reading 'The Overstory' and got to the part where a main character does something pretty extreme for the trees. Half our group thought it was a powerful, needed act of protest. The other half called it pointless eco-terrorism that ruined the character for them. The debate got so heated that Sarah from our club, who picked the book, actually left the Zoom call early. I tried to calm things down by asking if we could just talk about the writing style instead, but people were too fired up. We had to cancel the next meeting to cool off. It made me wonder, when a book club debate gets that personal, is it a sign of a really good book or a really bad group dynamic? Has your club ever had a fight that almost ended things, and how did you fix it?
4 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In4 Comments
jenny_lane1225d ago
Wow, that sounds rough. I get why you'd ask if it's the book or the group, but honestly, it's probably a bit of both. A good book should make you feel strongly, but a good group should know how to disagree without making someone leave the call. We had a blow-up over a character's dumb choice in a mystery novel once. The fix was boring: we made a rule that you have to talk about the fictional people like they're fictional, not like they're your personal enemy. It helped.
5
paul8724d ago
Rules for a book club? Seems like a lot of fuss over people talking about made-up stories. If a group needs that much structure to talk about a novel, maybe the problem isn't the book or the people, but taking it all too seriously. It's just a hobby.
3
amy_martin24d ago
Remember our rule about spoilers, Paul.
9
fionam1124d ago
Wait, you made a rule? @jenny_lane12
2