Update: my block's tree canopy went from 8 trees to 19 in 4 years, and the shade difference on my AC bill is real
Our street in Boise had almost no shade when we moved in back in 2021, and the asphalt got so hot in July that my dog would hop across it. A neighbor started a little tree planting push through the city's shade program, and we ended up adding 11 trees along the block over the next four years, mostly honey locust and linden since they handle the heat. Last month I compared my summer power bills, and July dropped from about $190 to $155 with the same thermostat settings. I know that's not all trees, but the late afternoon sun stopped hitting my west wall, and my AC actually shuts off now. The city covered most of the cost, I think we paid around $25 per tree for the permit and the first watering. Has anyone else measured a real drop after their block filled in, or is my number mostly just luck with a mild summer?
Walked my dog past a house last summer where the owner had planted a row of sunflowers along his west fence, and he swore his back bedroom stayed cooler all July. Never got a number out of him, but he was dead sure about it. It made me start watching how the light hits my own place, and honestly the trees make more sense than the flowers because they block the sun all afternoon, not just when it's low. Your $35 dip sounds about right for real shade on a west wall, even with a mild summer mixed in. The $25 per tree deal is the part that gets me, since that's cheaper than most people spend on mulch. Now I'm side eyeing my own bare front yard and wondering who I gotta call about the city program.
Read a piece from the Arbor Day Foundation that said trees placed on the west and southwest sides of a house can cut cooling costs by up to 25 percent, mostly by blocking that late day sun. Your $35 drop lines up with a modest chunk of that, so it probably isn't just a mild July. The part about your AC actually cycling off now is the real tell, since that means the wall itself is staying cooler and not soaking up heat all afternoon.