Loading…
6
Got into a heated debate about Frank Miller's Dark Knight at a con in Austin last weekend
This guy kept insisting it was overrated and I snapped, bringing up panels from memory. Ended up standing there for 45 minutes arguing about panel layouts outside the convention hall, has anyone else had a comic debate spiral like that?
4 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In4 Comments
jason_stone595mo ago
Dude, I just read this great piece breaking down Miller's use of the grid structure in those scenes, how the panels tighten up to match the rising tension. It really changed how I look at that whole second issue with the mutant leader fight. Thirty minutes flew by like nothing when I was arguing about the symbolism of the rain washing the blood off the sidewalk in those later pages.
6
johnson.river5mo ago
@torres.blair I hear you, but sometimes a good debate just feels worth it, you know?
-1
olivia_white934mo ago
Is there any chance that the whole "good debate" thing is just us trying to feel like we're part of something, even when we know it's pointless? I mean @torres.blair has a point about walking away, but sometimes the argument isn't even about changing someone's mind. It's about seeing if your own points hold up under pressure. Like when I was going back and forth with a guy about Miller's art style, and I realized halfway through that my whole take was actually shallow. That debate sucked but it made me think harder. So maybe it's not about winning, it's about testing your own ideas.
5