Ordered a 'secret menu' burger and it was a total disaster

Heard about a special burger online, the 'Animal Style Double Double' from In-N-Out. Tried it at the one off the 5 freeway. Got a burger that was basically soup in a wrapper. Mustard grilled patties, extra spread, grilled onions, pickles. Could not pick it up. Learned that some things are secret for a reason. Anyone have a good 'secret' item that actually works?

4 comments

4 Comments

smith.elliot19d ago

Ugh, that's the worst. I ask for the spread on the side now, makes it way easier to handle. Game changer for keeping it from falling apart.

wilson.olivia19d agoTop Commenter

Wait, but doesn't that make it too dry? I tried that and just ended up with a sad, plain sandwich. I have to spread it myself anyway.

derek_lee19d ago

Right? What is it with secret menu stuff always being a total mess? My "Protein Style" burger just fell apart into a lettuce pile on my lap.

the_blake19d ago

Game changer" is a bit strong, isn't it? The spread on the side just gives you a whole new problem of trying to spread cold, thick sauce on a burger that's already falling apart. You end up with a bigger mess and greasy fingers. It feels like they make these things hard to eat on purpose.